A recent study in the Journal of Empirical Finance analyzed hundreds of thousands of CEO tweets using IBM Watson Personality Insights to assess levels of neuroticism—a personality trait characterized by tendencies toward anxiety, anger, self-consciousness, and vulnerability.
The researchers found a fascinating correlation: companies led by neurotic CEOs tend to hold more cash, accumulate reserves more aggressively after economic downturns, and achieve higher firm value with lower credit risks.
While it’s easy to equate neuroticism with negative outcomes—hesitation, excessive caution, or strained team dynamics—this research highlights a counterintuitive benefit: neurotic CEOs often mitigate risk exceptionally well. Their heightened sensitivity to potential threats can drive them to create financial buffers that shield their companies in turbulent times.
In The CEO Tightrope, I’ve written about “paranoid optimism,” a mindset that balances realism with ambition. A neurotic CEO embodies this balance almost instinctively. Their predisposition toward worry can manifest as rigorous preparation—ensuring their organizations are insulated against shocks. This is particularly relevant in the current economic climate, where agility and resilience are paramount.
As I’ve often advised CEOs, a cash reserve is not merely a financial tool but a strategic buffer that can sustain operations, fund opportunities, and inspire confidence during uncertainty.
The Advantages of a Neurotic Mindset
Neuroticism, in moderation, has strategic advantages. Consider these findings:
Higher Cash Holdings: Neurotic CEOs often err on the side of caution, maintaining liquidity that allows their companies to weather storms without the need for expensive credit or rushed decisions.
Post-Downturn Recovery: Their instinct to rebuild reserves swiftly after economic disruptions prevents complacency and positions their organizations for quicker rebounds.
Enhanced Valuation: Investors and stakeholders value stability. Companies with robust cash reserves led by cautious leaders often appear safer and more reliable, reducing perceived risk.
In my advisory work, I’ve observed this dynamic firsthand. CEOs who lean into their anxieties productively can transform potential vulnerabilities into operational strengths.
For example, one leader I worked with, known for their cautious decision-making, ensured their company had a solid financial runway. When their industry faced an unexpected contraction, their business not only survived but emerged stronger, acquiring competitors at discounted valuations.
Keep reading with a 7-day free trial
Subscribe to Managing The Future to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.