Many leaders use the word accountability to mean “punishing someone when they screw up.”
Something went wrong? We have to find someone to blame. Someone has to be held accountable.
No wonder the word alone gives us a little spike of cortisol.
You often see leaders use the word accountability the most when they’re under pressure and need a scapegoat. (You see it in politics, too, all the time. Just look at the headlines.)
Whether they realize it or not, these leaders have found a management-guru-approved way of saying “Someone’s got to take the fall for this.” Funnily enough, it’s usually not themselves they want to hold accountable. In other words, it’s “Someone’s got to take the fall for this, and it won’t be me!”
But I think there’s a much healthier way to think about accountability, and many other leaders do a good job of it. This healthier way is regarding accountability as “commitment to objective reality.”
What do I mean by that?
When a team or a company culture is defined by lack of accountability, it’s not that people aren’t being punished enough. It’s usually instead that people have drifted from a shared sense of objective reality:
Goals are vague, and morph to whatever form is convenient for discussion without making people feel bad.
Subpar work performance is regarded as perfectly fine. They tried!
When a ball is dropped, the reaction is “What ball? I don’t remember a ball…”
A good leader does not allow subjective, malleable reality to reign in this way. Rather, the good leader holds people accountable through a commitment to objective reality:
“We set this specific goal. Will we achieve it?”
“That report/presentation/design wasn’t where it needed to be. Here’s how we can do it differently next time.”
“We dropped the ball on this. Let’s make a plan to get it back on track.”
That’s real accountability.
Imagine Tom Brady making three bad throws in a row and Bill Belichick just saying, “No worries, Tom! You did a great job! Maybe next time.” That’s not what happens on a winning team. If Brady misses a throw, Belichick makes damn sure he knows he threw it over their head. It doesn’t matter that the receiver didn’t run quite the right route or that the lineman didn’t block well enough. The coach’s job is to make the player acknowledge objective reality. It’s the only way the player—or the team—can get better.
Accountability doesn’t mean anyone needs to be punished, made to feel bad, or forced to grovel.
It means, rather, that the leader must do the thankless but critical work of holding everyone to a shared, objective reality.
Without it, everything devolves to excuses and illusion.



