John A. Allison once said to me, “You can judge a CEO by what happens in the year after they leave.”
It’s a wise insight. The full effect of a CEO’s leadership isn’t always seen in the first 100 days, the first year, or even the first five years of their tenure. Only once they step away can you truly tell how well they were running the company.
For one, you see how strong of a system they built. If the CEO applied a durable set of practices and processes that keep running even in their absence, they set their successor up for success. That’s one of the biggest blessings a new CEO can ask for and a strong sign of organizational health.
Second, when a CEO steps away from the job voluntarily, you see how much thought they put into their successor. These transitions are some of the most consequential moments in the life of a business—and a common way for CEOs to make terrible mistakes.
In today’s Managing the Future, we’re doing something a little different. In place of the usual economic rundown is a Crash Report, in which we look at the recent troubles of Philadelphia-based pharmacy chain Rite Aid. Last Sunday, Rite Aid filed for bankruptcy protection and this week announced the closure of 154 stores in 10 states.
As you’ll see in the report, I think you can trace Rite Aid’s troubles back to a poor succession process. In 1995, cost-conscious Rite Aid founder Alex Grass passed the baton to his 44-year-old son, Martin Grass, who’d been waiting in the wings nearly two decades for his time in the CEO chair.
What happened next is worthy of a Greek tragedian. The younger Grass, hard-charging and ambitious, went on an acquisition spree, making the type of deals—and taking on levels of debt—his father had always resisted. Martin’s strategy initially appeared to be working; Rite Aid’s profits grew slightly in tandem with its competitors. Then it all fell apart.
In the late 1990s, Rite Aid’s stock plummeted from the neighborhood of $50 to less than $2. Debt spiraled. And, when it was discovered that Martin and other Rite Aid executives had been overstating income and engaging in other illegal accounting practices, Martin ended up behind bars. He served six years of an eight-year sentence.
As evidenced by this week’s news, Rite Aid never recovered from that original sin of Alex Grass’s poorly considered CEO transition to his son. Soon after Alex left, Rite Aid became the plagued entity it has been ever since.
If you are currently serving as CEO, I encourage you to think about your own hopes in this area. What do you want to happen in the year after you leave your current role? What can you do now to make that happen?
Have a good weekend and see you in the next edition.
—Joel



