The most critical role of a board of directors is hiring and firing the CEO.
If you’re on a board and you have a CEO transition on the horizon (maybe Coldplay is coming to town), I urge you to be aware of a CEO-hiring misstep I see boards make, or almost make, repeatedly.
First, I want to explain why this error happens: Most board members have never been in the CEO seat. They therefore do not have a first-person experience of what the CEO does. This doesn’t mean they cannot still be good board members, but it does mean they need to put in a little extra work to understand how to hire and fire the CEO properly.
Now, let’s say a board is faced with a situation where they need to hire a new CEO. Maybe it’s a software company where revenue has been flat for two years.
Three candidates for the new CEO emerge:
Candidate A is a VP of Sales with a track record of hitting numbers. He speaks confidently about driving growth and has stories about landing major deals. He reminds many board members of themselves and just seems like a convincing rainmaker.
Candidate B started in product management but has spent the last five years in general management roles. She's a little less polished and quieter but asks thoughtful questions about operational processes and customer retention.
Candidate C has a marketing background but later founded a couple of companies himself. One fizzled out but the other he scaled and exited successfully. He's exploratory in his approach and focuses on underlying business fundamentals.
Which candidate do most boards choose?
The sales leader, almost every time. And that's often the wrong choice, maybe even the worst choice.
Understanding the Three-Function Model
In training CEOs, I teach a simple framework: every business has three core functions that ultimately drive success—Product/Service, Marketing, and Sales. Each has a specific role:
Product/Service solves customer problems effectively and efficiently
Marketing identifies and engages qualified customers
Sales maximizes perceived customer value
Revenue problems can originate from any of these three functions. But boards often default to thinking it's a sales problem because that's what they focus on most. The revenue impact feels most immediate to them.
Why not hire a sales-focused CEO, then?
Well, if the real problem is a flawed product that customers don't want, or market positioning that's completely off-target, no amount of sales talent will fix the underlying issue.
The best CEOs understand that their job is not to excel at one function, but to balance all three and make smart tradeoffs between them.
Three Questions for Better CEO Hiring
Sales professionals make compelling CEO candidates because they're natural performers who speak the language of results. They project confidence and will fluently discuss growth targets. It’s exactly what anxious boards want to hear.
But here's the problem: the temperament that makes someone excellent at sales often makes them poorly suited for the CEO role. A great salesperson often focuses on optimizing for immediate results. They may be lone wolves, too, who don’t excel at aligning and engaging teams. Sales pros can make good CEOs, but the point is that they often present as the perfect candidate to the board, who then find themselves sorely disappointed six months later when all the old problems remain.
The best boards ask different questions:
What's really broken? Don't assume declining revenue means you have a sales problem. Is it really a sales execution problem, or is it product-market fit? Is our positioning wrong? Are we solving the right customer problems?
What does this situation actually require? Different problems need different skill sets. Match the leader to the challenge.
Does this candidate understand the interdependencies? Look for evidence they can balance competing priorities across all three functions, not just optimize one area.
The CEO's job is to optimize the entire system. Board members who understand this will make better hiring decisions and see better results rather than being swayed by the charisma and promise of a sales-forward candidate.



